Most Durable Luggage 2017 – Top 5 Carry-Ons And Checked Luggage!
Is there anything more annoying than trying to zip up your bag at the hotel and the zipper breaks? And it can be really stressful as well if you have a plane or train to catch, and not really the time to rush to a store and buy new luggage to put your stuff in.
Or what about running through the airport actually CARRYING a heavy bag, because one of the wheels just broke and made it impossible to either pull or push?
Here at Travel Gear Depot we don’t want you to have such bad experiences. Thus, we have scrutinized the web and picked out what we believe to be among the most durable luggage you can find. We have chosen 2 carry-ons and 3 suitcases. Often there is a product line, which means you can find suitcases from the same line as a carry-on we have recommended, and vice versa.
We will start with some general questions about durable luggage, and then dive into the specific product reviews. Enjoy!
Read everything from top to bottom, or hop to the heading you’re most interested in by clicking on it in the table of contents below.
- How Durable Is Hardside Luggage?
- How Durable Is Polycarbonate Luggage?
- What Is the Most Durable Luggage Material?
- Is There Luggage With Durable Wheels?
- Who Makes the Most Durable Luggage?
- Victorinox Spectra 2.0 Compact Global Carry On
- Briggs & Riley Baseline Commuter Expandable Upright
- Travelpro Luggage Platinum Magna 21 Inch Expandable Spinner Suiter
- Eagle Creek EC Adventure 25 Inch Luggage
- Samsonite Luggage Inova Spinner 28
- Share this:
How Durable Is Hardside Luggage?
There seems to be a common view that soft side luggage by default is more durable than hard sided. This may have been true earlier on when the plastic that was used for manufacturing was far more fragile than the materials used today.
Nowadays, new durable materials have seen the day of light. This has made the statement that hard side bags are not as durable false, in our opinion. There’s no need to avoid hard side luggage for the sake of durability anymore!
How Durable Is Polycarbonate Luggage?
The answer to his question is quite simple: it’s very durable! The main reason for this is the fact that it is flexible and thus impact resistant. It simply flexes back into shape after a thud onto a hard surface.
Polycarbonate is also very lightweight, more so than aluminium and many soft side bags.
What Is the Most Durable Luggage Material?
If you’re after durable luggage and are happy with a soft side, ballistic nylon is the material to look for. But, there’s more to it than that.
Ever heard of denier? The most common everyday place you might hear of it is when you buy tights. 10D tights are very sheer, and leggings would be around 200D. So denier is a measure of the thickness of the threads going into the fabric.
For a suitcase, the denier should be at least 1000 and up to 2000. Otherwise the nylon will not be abrasion resistant enough.
Is There Luggage With Durable Wheels?
Now this is a tricky one!
We normally consider the inline roller bags with two wheels, also called inline skate wheels, more durable than spinners. The latter has four or eight wheels. This is mainly because the wheels of the inliners are far better protected than the wheels of the spinners.
However, here as well as with the hard side bags, there has been development and progress. Spinner wheels are not as fragile as when they first got popular, and may hold up very well if the luggage is a high-quality piece. This is especially true when it comes to carry-ons that will not get rough-handled by airport personnel.
It also matters what material the wheels are made of. Most durable is polyurethane, a kind of plastic that is highly resilient and flexible. Other plastics and rubber may wear down too fast, making the wheels not so round and prone to jam.
Our answer to the question in the heading is then a yes, there most certainly is luggage with durable wheels out there! We have taken this point into consideration when reviewing the bags in this article.
Who Makes the Most Durable Luggage?
If the question above about the durability of wheels was a tricky one, this is even more so. Most luggage brands have several product lines. Some of them are low budget ones made with less expensive materials, while others are more designed for quality and outstanding longevity.
Our five product reviews in this article are about bags from five different brands. This shows that it’s hard to nail down one specific brand as the most durable one.
(You may also like to read our article on what we believe to be the best luggage brands today.)
Alright then, let’s get on with our reviews!
Victorinox Spectra 2.0 Compact Global Carry On
- Overall size: 21.6” x 13.8” x 7.9”
- Weight: 5.15 lbs.
- Warranty: Global Ten Year Limited Warranty (covers manufactural defects only)
Victorinox has a well-earned reputation for high-quality products. Did you know that the company started off with making knives already in 1884? The name Victorinox is composed of the name of the founder’s mother, Victoria, and the international term for stainless steel, InoxHence, Victorinox!
Fun facts, but let’s dig into the features of this bag.
The shell is made of extremely durable Bayer polycarbonate. Due to the matte finish it also manages to be highly scratch resistant.
It is equipped with 4 soft-tread, dual-caster spinner wheels. We have seen a couple of reviewers complaining about the quality of these. But, our overall impression is that they are definitely good enough. The complaints were actually that a wheel broke and fell off. We somehow think that if this happens on the odd bag, it is due to some manufactural once-in-a-while error. The warranty should definitely cover this.
The bag has a dual-trolley aluminum handle that locks in three heights, and a top handle for carrying and lifting it into the overhead bin.
We are happy that it is also equipped with a TSA-approved combination lock, so there is no need for a padlock.
The insides are fine, but nothing special to be honest. A zippered mesh divider, a zippered pocket, and Y-shaped cross straps. Works fine we believe!
Victorinox offers their Swiss Tracker™ Bag Tracking Program, which enables you to meet your bag again in case it gets lost, for free! All you need to do is register your bag’s ID number at victorinox.com.
If you are afraid to forget the combination you’ve chosen for the lock (and we are and do!) you can register that too!
We are happy with this bag and believe it to be a very good buy if you are looking for a durable hard side carry-on!
Briggs & Riley Baseline Commuter Expandable Upright
- Overall size: 19” x 14” x 9”
- Weight: 8.1 lbs.
- Warranty: ”Simple as that® ” – covers the repair of all functional aspects, whatever the cause, for lifetime of the bag
In a hurry? Click here to go directly to Amazon and check out today’s price and availability!
Now this is a carry-on for the very frequent business traveler! It doesn’t show off with beautiful design or vibrant colors. Instead, it delivers what its somewhat bland exterior seems to promise: functionality and durability.
This is a two-wheeled inliner, and inline wheels are usually the most durable choice. They are som much better protected than the spinner wheels.
There is actually so much that is good with this carry-on that it’s hard to mention it all! But we’ll pick out the best parts 😉
The bag has the awesome CX™ Expansion-Compression Technology, which allows you to expand and overstuff your bag and then compress it back to carry-on size. Magic!
There is a large front pocket and extra outside pockets on the front and on the back for those items you need to access quickly, like boarding card and passport. Or perhaps a foldable umbrella!
The trolley-handle has been fitted on the outside, so it doesn’t steal any of the interior space, and leaves a flat surface for packing. The handle itself is made from aluminum and shaped in a V-groove to make it stronger and lessen the risk of jamming. It has three stop heights.
The bag is kept in shape by a hybrid fiberglass frame. The 2520 denier ballistic nylon effectively resists abrasion, dirt and water. A padlock for the main compartment is needed since there is no lock integrated on the bag.
The interior is lined with a lightly colored fabric so you can easily see your items against it. At the bottom is cinch-down mesh garment panels. They are perfect for keeping your garments from shifting and keep them as wrinkle free as possible.
The so-called Smartlink™ Strap enables you to tie another, smaller bag to this one piggy-back style, so you can handle two bags as one.
We can only bow to the perfection of this bag. If you’re looking for a truly and completely durable carry-on bag, this is the one to buy. An extra plus is the size, at a height of 19” it complies with the carry-on size restrictions of most airlines. But remember, always check with the airline you’re flying with!
Travelpro Luggage Platinum Magna 21 Inch Expandable Spinner Suiter
- Overall size: 22.5″ x 14″ x 9″
- Weight: 7.9 lbs.
- Warranty: Worry Free Warranty, covers repair for the lifetime of the bag, even if damaged in transit
The Platinum Magna collection from Travelpro is the company’s high-quality line, with the excellent Worry Free warranty, which is comparable to Briggs & Rileys ”Simple as that”.
This carry-on is a spinner with so-called MagnaTrac™ dual wheels. They are self-aligning by the force of magnetism. This feature seems to work very well according to reviewers across the web. One person though was slightly annoyed that the bag rolled away easily if left on an incline.
The soft shell is made of very sturdy and abrasion-resistant 1682D nylon, with Duraguard coating for easy cleaning. On the front are two zippered pockets, be aware though that the outer pocket only opens at the very top, making it a bit awkward to use. The larger opens all the way down and may hold a tablet or smaller laptop.
The dual trolley-handle is made of aluminum and equipped with a contour grip. It has three stops. There is also top and side leather handles, and a handle cup at the bottom for easy carrying and handling.
The bag is stabilized by a one piece frame construction that is called Duraframe. You do need to buy a padlock since there is no integrated lock.
The interior is fully lined and has a garment bag and a suiter compartment. As in the Briggs & Riley bag there are mesh garment panels at the bottom to keep your shirts as wrinkle free as possible. There is a long zippered pocket along the side and two small on the garment panels.
There is one negative thing we have found that more than reviewer complains about, and that is the fact that the bag easily falls over when you let go of it. It may be a real nuisance if you have to support the bag to prevent it from tipping.
Some reviewers have also complained that the alleged height of 21 inches is actually more like 22.5 inches. Here we have given the 22.5-measurement.
We think this is a fairly good bag but with some flaws, the major ones being the tipping over and the tendency for it to become a runaway when left on an incline. As we so often say, you usually get what you pay for… 😉
Eagle Creek EC Adventure 25 Inch Luggage
- Overall size: 25″ x 17″ x 12″ (expanded 14”)
- Weight: 8.6 lbs.
- Warranty: No Matter What, covers repair for the lifetime of the bag, even if damaged in transit
Eagle Creek delivers as usual. When it comes to durable luggage we firmly believe that this brand is a winner. So what’s so great about this bag then?
The two wheels (and that alone stands for some of the durability!) roll effortlessly in any terrain, due to the fact that they are large and treaded.
The soft shell is composed of three different fabrics, 600D Poly Ripstop , 600D Helix Oxford and 1260D Helix Ballistic. There are two zippered front pockets, lockable if you like. On the top and side there are padded handles and there is a grab handle at the bottom (which also works as support when the bag is standing).
At the top is a handle tray that protects the expandable handle system, there are corner bumpers that also protect the wheels, a kick plate and reinforcements on each corner.
In the large front pocket is a piggyback clip attached, so you can add a second bag and handle them as one. On the second front compartment is a small pocket with a slip-away ID tag.
The main compartment of the bag has a divider/door panel and compression wings to keep your clothes in order, and it is fully lined with a light fabric. It’s 15% expandable.
There is nothing more to wish for when it comes to durability in checked luggage. To keep your belongings completely organised, consider using it with Eagle Creek’s Pack-It™ System, and you have a piece of luggage that will work for life.
Samsonite Luggage Inova Spinner 28
- Overall size: 29.75″ x 20.0″ x 11.0″
- Weight: 9.46 lbs.
- Warranty: Limited 10 Year Global Warranty
This is another hard side polycarbonate bag, in checked luggage size this time. For a suitcase this size, it’s fairly lightweight.
Most reviewers on the web are happy with this bag. It looks great and stylish with the textured metallic-like finish, and rolls easily on its four dual spinner wheels. We have seen no negative reviews concerning the wheels.
The interior is simple, two zippered dividers on each side of the fully lined bag and cross-straps. Nothing more.
The retractable handle is a mono bar, which seems to hold up nicely. As noticed before we are surprised on how comfortable the grip feels on a mono bar. There is a top and a side handle for carrying and lifting.
On top is an integrated TSA-approved combination lock. The zipper that goes all the way around the bag is protected with a kind of rubber lining. One reviewer pointed out that if the bag is not fully packed, the sides get squeezed together and difficult to unzip.
Although reviews are mostly positive, there are two possible cons we want to share:
A couple of reviews mention that the two sides are connected by rubber hinges that seem to be somewhat flimsy. Also, we have spotted a few users commenting that the bag gets easily scratched. However, this doesn’t really affect the durability, which seems good, but more the looks. As one person put in his/her comment: if you are a perfectionist, do not buy this luggage.
This is a durable hardside, polycarbonate bag that holds up well when getting tossed around in transit. As for the hinges, we haven’t actually seen anyone complaining that they have broken, so they might very well be good enough.
So, considering the many positive reviews we do recommend this bag, with the slight reservation about the scratching.
Hey, you’re not forgetting about Black Friday, right? Check in when it’s drawing close, we’ll keep an eye out for the very best luggage deals for you!